Skip to main content

User account menu

  • Log in
Shopping cart 0
Cart

Search

Search
Home The Enterprise-Tocsin
  • Post
    • Post Dashboard
    • Leaderboard
    • Payment Settings
  • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Monthly Website Statistics
    • Our History
    • Our Staff
    • Privacy Policy
    • Rack Locations
    • Submit News
  • Most Read
    • Most Read This Week
    • Most Read This Month
    • Most Read This Year
    • Most Read All Time
  • Most Recent
  • More News
    • Cartoons
    • Crime
    • Documents
    • Videos
    • Features
    • Politics
    • Public Notices
  • Sports
  • E-Editions
    • Archives
    • Newspaper E-Edition
    • Magazine
    • Special Sections
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Comments
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Submit a Letter to the Editor
  • Advertising
    • Ad Rates
    • Ad Staff
  • Calendar
  • Obituaries
    • Submit an Obituary
  • Social
    • Anniversaries/Birthdays
    • Engagements/Weddings
    • Schools
    • Submit an Anniversary
    • Submit a Birth
    • Submit an Engagement
    • Submit School News
    • Submit a Wedding
  • Subscribe
  • State

Domain menu for The Enterprise-Tocsin (main)

  • Post
    • Post Dashboard
    • Leaderboard
    • Payment Settings
  • Home
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Monthly Website Statistics
    • Our History
    • Our Staff
    • Privacy Policy
    • Rack Locations
    • Submit News
  • Most Read
  • Most Recent
  • More News
    • Cartoons
    • Crime
    • Documents
    • Videos
    • Features
    • Politics
    • Public Notices
  • Sports
  • E-Editions
    • Archives
    • Newspaper E-Edition
    • Magazine
    • Special Sections
  • Opinion
    • Columns
    • Comments
    • Editorials
    • Letters
    • Submit a Letter to the Editor
  • Advertising
    • Ad Rates
    • Ad Staff
  • Calendar
  • Obituaries
    • Submit an Obituary
  • Social
    • Anniversaries/Birthdays
    • Engagements/Weddings
    • Schools
    • Submit an Anniversary
    • Submit a Birth
    • Submit an Engagement
    • Submit School News
    • Submit a Wedding
  • Subscribe
  • State

What's wrong with government regulated monopolies

By Kelley Williams: Bigger Pie , READ MORE > 1,606 Reads
On Mon, 02/24/2020 - 09:05 AM

Nothing if you are one. Like Entergy Mississippi and Mississippi Power. Regulated monopolies are largely protected from competition and are great for their shareholders. Not so great for their customers though. Especially if the regulator, the Public Service Commission (PSC), has its thumb on the scale for the monopoly. 

And if the utilities’ armies of lobbyists out-mans or out-womans and out-spends and out-entertains and consequently out-influences the Legislature, which makes the rules for its regulator to favor utilities. It’s a slam dunk for utilities in the Legislature since most of their customers don’t have lobbyists. Or anyone else to speak just for them. 

So, the Legislature makes a rule telling the PSC to put its thumb on the scale for the monopolies. And the monopolies’ advertising and public relations campaigns make customers think their electric rates are a bargain. And that solar plants and other green energy experiments will generate electricity cheaper than plants running on natural gas. And that billions spent to build and maintain Entergy’s old Grand Gulf nuclear plant, which runs occasionally, are a good deal for customers. And so on.

We have written before about how regulated monopolies and their political allies deceive customers. You may remember Mississippi Power’s Kemper County Lignite Plant. It was a scheme to charge customers for an expensive green energy experiment to turn low-grade coal (lignite) into synthetic natural gas to generate electricity. Its hopelessly complicated Rube Goldberg gasifier failed as predicted. So, Mississippi Power and its Southern Company parent wrote off over $6 billion they planned to mark up and pass on to customers.

Many politicians and two of the three PSC Commissioners backed the expensive Kemper experiment.  So did the Public Utilities Staff (PUS) — a state agency created after a Grand Gulf scandal sent two PSC Commissioners to prison. It’s supposed to advise and keep an eye on the PSC. Some watchdog. 

Support for Kemper and its higher rates lasted until more information made it politically toxic. 

If you wonder why anyone would back an expensive experiment versus a cheaper proven alternative, it’s because utility monopolies make more money from expensive plants than from cheap plants.  They get a guaranteed profit (return) on the money they spend (capital invested). So, the more they spend, the more they make.

And the more they make, the more favors they can do. And the more favors they do, the more political friends they have. 

We want to take the PSC’s thumb off the scale for utilities. One of our board members tried to call a Legislative Committee Chair about this last year. He reached her at a Saints game — in the Entergy Box. 

Ironically, that game is remembered for a thumb-on-the-scale officiating mistake. A pass interference no-call (probably inadvertent) hurt the Saints chance to make the Super Bowl.

But the thumb-on-the-scale rule is not inadvertent. It explicitly requires the PUS to “balance” the interests of customers and utilities and implicitly requires the PSC to do so. It’s like saying your lawyer must represent the other side too. And the judge must always split the baby. 

Utilities have armies of lawyers and consultants to persuade the PSC to increase rates. They can jump through rate case hearing docket hoops for their clients. A few large customers have lawyers and consultants to jump through PSC hoops too and get them sweetheart contracts (confidential contracts that other customers don’t see). But most customers don’t have anyone to speak for them. And the utilities like it that way.

We think the PSC should put customers’ interests first. Especially small customers.  We want a  state customer or consumer advocate to represent those customers who have no effective voice now. Studies show this works in other states. Such advocates level the regulatory playing field somewhat and reduce the officiating advantage utilities enjoy. 

The Public Utilities Staff can be charged and reorganized to do this. It can also continue to provide expert analyses for the PSC to counter-balance utility experts in an adversarial proceeding and help the PSC make better and fairer decisions. No more Kempers.

Now there is a new omnibus rule before the PSC. It’s called the Integrated Resource Planning Rule. It may be a good idea - for utilities. It must be because they got it passed. Now they want to write the fine print to implement it without help from anyone representing their customers.

Utilities (specifically Mississippi Power) don’t want Bigger Pie to comment or intervene on the bill in behalf of customers who don’t have the time or money or expertise to do so. Or on behalf of the general public and state’s economy which is hurt by high electric rates. 

The IRP Rule says utility monopolies should foresee and plan for the future.  Other states have such rules. The idea is if utility monopolies think about future electric demand and supply, they will do a better job of providing an economically reliable supply.  And customers and the economy will be better off. Sounds good. Who could be against that? 

It’s hard to argue with those objectives.  If they benefit customers. So, why not let Bigger Pie comment on and help with the plan? Possibly for the same reasons Mississippi Power and the PSC didn’t answer Bigger Pie’s questions about Kemper’s incomplete engineering, rigged projections about future natural gas prices, and optimistic assumptions about technological risk. The answer then was hubris and things to hide. The result was the biggest political boondoggle in the state’s history.

Same answer now? Happy Valentine’s Day.

Kelley Williams, a Northsider, is chairman of Bigger Pie, a Jackson-based think tank promoting free markets and government efficiency.

‹ PreviousNext ›

Social

Music From The Ground Up Video Series Set To Launch

Music From The Ground Up, a locally produced music video series featuring local Delta musicians… READ MORE

Wilson, Moorman to wed March 6
Hazel Black Pierce
Birth Announcement: Lyla Marie Davidson welcomed
Suddoth, Hargett to wed
Giachelli, Grimes to wed Saturday

Most Recent

‘Food that’s going to stick to your ribs’: The significance of soul food in Yalobusha County

Marie Gaston still remembers all the food her parents cooked when she was growing up.

MDCC Softball Starts Conference Play Saturday
Wicker Leads Push for Local Infrastructure
Hyde-Smith, Colleagues Introduce ‘Save Democracy Act’ to Restore Confidence in Elections
Wicker, Hyde-Smith & Guest Announce $5.26 Million for Rural Health, Education Projects
Wicker, Hyde-Smith Ask DOD to Commit to Navy Shipbuilding Requirements

Most Read News Article

  • Week
  • Month
  • Year
  • All Time

Demario Davis’ second chance

Three years ago, Fox News commentator Laura Ingraham unwisely advised basketball superstars LeBron… READ MORE

Marshall Ramsey: H2-No
‘Food that’s going to stick to your ribs’: The significance of soul food in Yalobusha County
Hyde-Smith announces $86.1 million defense logistics contract to Mississippi company
Man charged in Saturday night stabbing
Wicker, Hyde-Smith commend Corinth & Petal students picked for 2021 U.S. Senate Youth Program

Sheriff says Inverness DG theft an inside job, arrest made

An early morning visit to the Inverness Dollar General store has netted a charge for one store… READ MORE

Putnam Gets Save in First Collegiate Game
Accident claims the life of local woman
Anthony Gives Update on Fourth Session Week
The Family Tradition: The same dream that brought his family from Missouri to Mississippi over 50 years ago is still alive today for Ruleville farmer Zac Tollison
IFMG To Close Clinics Monday Due To Inclement Weather

Loved ones remember young woman shot and killed last Friday

On Friday, April 10, Alberta Garner’s life was cut short just before dawn after shots rang out on… READ MORE

B.B. King Museum among many awarded MDNHA grants
USDA approves Mississippi to receive Pandemic-EBT benefits
Friday morning shooting in Moorhead may have been retaliation for 2019 murder
Three arrested, one sought in Friday night shooting death
B.B. King Museum closes through end of March

FUMC praise band releases second studio album

These days, it’s hard to find a large church that does not have a contemporary praise band.Many,… READ MORE

MDCC alumni event, golf tournament this month
MDCC to open bids for Stauffer-Wood renovation
Rasberry men to present black history program
Candidates meet in public forum
Church encourages athletes to ‘pursue God’

Sign Up for Notifications of Local Breaking News

Start E-mail NotificationsStop E-mail NotificationsStart Mobile NotificationsStop Mobile Notifications

E-Edition Button

Obituaries

Earlean Sibley

Graveside services for Earlean Sibley of Greenwood, formerly of Inverness, will be at 1:30 p.m.

Opinion

Mission accomplished

Even in the throes of the COVID-19 pandemic, I never thought of the possibility of missing a paper.

Do we really need February? Yes, no, maybe?
History will light the path to the future
Dunagin: Why fix what's not broken?
PERS trend is unsustainable
Get ready for the potholes

Weddings and Engagement

Wilson, Moorman to wed March 6

Mr. and Mrs. Jimmy Mitchell Wilson of Linn announce the wedding of their daughter, Ms. Erin Austin… READ MORE

Lee, McGill to wed in Inverness Jan. 30
Suddoth, Hargett to wed
Giachelli, Grimes to wed Saturday
A Facetime proposal
Grubb, Goff to wed October 24

Sports

MDCC Softball Starts Conference Play Saturday

The Mississippi Delta Community College softball program will begin a trek toward postseason play… READ MORE

COMPANY COMMUNITY ADVERTISE E-EDITIONS MORE NEWS
Contact Community Calendar Subscribe Magazine E-Edition Cartoons
FAQ/Help Obituaries Ad Rates Newspaper Archive Columns
Our History Engagements/Weddings Ad Staff Newspaper E-Edition Editorials
Our Staff Most Read My Account Special Section Features
Statewide Most Recent Rack Locations    

Click on the city name to visit its website.

ACKERMAN  •  CARROLLTON  •  CHARLESTON  •  CLARKSDALE  •  COLUMBIA  •  DUMAS(Ark.)  •  EUPORA  •  FOREST  • 

FRANKLINTON(La.)  • GREENVILLE  •  GREENWOOD  •  GRENADA  •  HATTIESBURG  •  JACKSON  •  KOSCIUSKO  •  INDIANOLA  • 

LOUISVILLE  • MAGEE  • MENDENHALL  •  McCOMB  •  NEWTON  •  PETAL  •  QUITMAN  •  SENATOBIA  •  TALLULAH(La.)  •  WINONA  •  YAZOO CITY


Copyright 2020 - The Enterprise-Tocsin | Privacy Statement | Help | Terms of Service

The Enterprise-Tocsin - 114 Main St.- Indianola, MS 38751 - (662)-887-2222

Emmerich Newspapers proud to serve your local communities.

Thank you for visiting our website.